Caroline Myss - The Language of Archetypes (Discover the Forces That Shape Your Destiny)
A good friend recommended this set of 10 CDs by
Caroline Myss, "
Medical Intuitive" giving lecture on the power of archetypes. I happily jumped into listening to the program since I am very much interested in human behaviour, its motivations, intrinsic or environmental determinants. Well, I was treated to somewhat of a cold shower.
Caroline Myss basically provides a who's who of character and situation archetypes discovered by others, mixed with some overstated obvious truths and a touch of ego trip.
If one has never heard or read about the world of archetypes before, it may not be a wasted time listening to these CDs. One can get a catalog of named archetypes with some (mostly "intuitive") explanation around them. For the most part the "shadow side" discussion of the various archetypes can be interesting as it brings in some reference to excessive or misdirected application of the archetypes.
There a few issues with the way she presents what she has to say on the subject. Number one is the treatment of the subject not as a speculation now widely accepted or a study based on empirical analysis of human behaviour, but a set of hard-core facts cast into humans by some external force, that for the most part the human does not really have a lot of direct control over. My usual beef is that there are all too many schools of thought helping people avoid any responsibility in their own actions. This is another one. If the "good Samaritan" archetype is not in me, then why should it be not OK for me not to help a person who is desperate need?! I just can't help it...it's not in me...
To her archetypes are not generic versions of a personality, which they are to me, but strict classes into which humans belong whether they like it or not. In Myss' view archetypes evolve within us not giving much thought to their hosts, as it were, rather than our life going through changes for various internal or external reasons, and consequently our personality changing to accommodate or to resist such changes.
There is no such thing as straight talk for her. Repeatedly she makes claims that anyone saying anything to her or others is really nothing but a charade for various archetypal intentions that are rather different from the actual words spoken. But she, obviously, reads very clearly amongst these, and truth is never hidden from her while others would have no clue about such things. True, there are covert motives in a number of things people say. Still, I find this a touch too arrogant that hardly anything people say should be taken as is but always a clairvoyant has to interpret true meaning. Just does not work for me.
Caroline Myss' declaration that "I don't do kids...I can't stand them around me..." was a turn-off for me as well. It has nothing to do with the merits of the program. It just says something about the person.
Intolerant references to new age and organized religion of any kind (most notable anything to do with Christianity is a bad do) are also abundant. The one about new age is actually a bit kinky since she actually is preaching some of the same things that define new age... Hmm.
Finally, no reference to where she got her material. Perhaps some credit to the works of C. G. Jung and other pioneers of the field who actually defined such archetypes as The Shadow, Anima/Animus, The Divine Couple (Syzygy), The Child, etc. or even classic authors such as Plato for his theory of ideas would have been appropriate.